YCBA Collections Search

This work is a testament to Dobson's painterly talent and to the promise of a career that would be cut short by his death in 1646. Passed down in the Streatfeild family of Chiddingstone, Kent, it has therefore traditionally been thought to represent Richard Streatfeild (1611-1676 ), his wife Ann, and three of their children. The Streatfeilds were ironmasters whose financial success had placed them by the mid-seventeenth century among the wealthier members of the region's gentry. Dobson creates a compelling portrait of a family whose destiny is fraught with the uncertainty of living in a nation imperiled and ravaged by civil war. Rich passages of light and shadow, particularly in the dreamy, almost melancholic face of the man, suffuse the canvas with a somber tone.
The father's hand on the head of the boy at the left would designate him as Henry, eldest son and heir (b. 1639). Unfortunately, the identities of the two other children remain shrouded in mystery; following Henry, the Streatfeilds had seven more children, among whom the only four to survive were born after this portrait was painted. The enigmatic allegorical symbols-the three cherries held up by the youngest child to the father; the strangely unclothed, impish, and inexplicable child who smiles mysteriously at the viewer; and the four foreboding skulls piled atop the broken pedestal-compel us to read into the picture meanings of mourning, loss, and even, perhaps, a stoic faith in providence. Ultimately the portrait conveys the realities-both affectionate and disturbing-of family life in mid-seventeenth-century England.
Originally identified as by Dobson in 1957, the portrait is now accepted as one of his relatively few known works. Nevertheless, questions remain as to how much of the extant picture is by Dobson's own hand and which areas belong to his original design. The debate centers on the wide piece of canvas that has been added to the left side of the painting. The seam, clearly visible to the left of the central male figure, runs vertically the height of the canvas, effectively severing the man's right arm from his shoulder and separating the two small children on the left from the other three figures. It was long postulated that this additional section was joined to the canvas after Dobson's death so as to add children to the composition as they came into the family. Certainly, an artist other than Dobson painted these children, who are clearly by a less accomplished hand. But, as Malcolm Rogers has convincingly suggested, Dobson most likely added the strip of canvas himself, designing the present composition but leaving the work unfinished.

Julia Marciari-Alexander

Julia Marciari-Alexander, This other Eden, paintings from the Yale Center for British Art, Yale Center for British Art, New Haven, CT, 1998, p. 32, no. 5, ND1314.3 Y36 1998 (YCBA)